America's Must-Read Book at Present Moment

America's Must-Read Book at Present Moment

The future of the United States is shrouded in uncertainty, with the weakening of democratic institutions and rising economic inequality raising concerns about its prosperity. Nobel laureates Daron Acemoglu, James Robinson, and Simon Johnson have highlighted this issue in their groundbreaking book, Why Nations Fail, which argues that the strength and fairness of institutions, not culture or geography, determine a nation's fate.

In Why Nations Fail, Acemoglu and Robinson contend that the long-term weakening of democratic institutions combined with economic inequality leads to a nation’s decline in prosperity. They emphasize that nations with inclusive institutions — which distribute power broadly, uphold the rule of law, encourage innovation, and allow fair competition — are more likely to prosper. In contrast, extractive institutions, where a small elite controls political and economic power, lead to stagnation, inequality, and eventual failure.

The weakening of democratic institutions undermines pillars such as innovation, fair competition, and strong governance. When political power concentrates and institutions become extractive, it results in widening economic inequality and hinders inclusive economic growth. This dynamic gradually erodes the foundations of prosperity, leading to stagnation and decline over time.

Acemoglu and Robinson show through historical and contemporary examples that institutional drift — a shift from inclusive to extractive systems — can set nations on paths toward failure. They also highlight that breaking out of poverty does not come from geography, culture, or natural resources but from building inclusive political and economic institutions that empower broad coalitions of citizens and sustain freedoms like a free press and political participation.

The tale of Nogales, a town divided between Arizona and Mexico, and the division of North and South Korea are compelling illustrations of the power of institutions in shaping a nation's prosperity. While both North and South Korea shared similar destruction after the Korean War, their institutional choices led to starkly different outcomes. South Korea embraced inclusive institutions, transforming it from one of the poorest countries into a developed, high-income nation, while North Korea adopted a centrally planned, communist system with highly extractive institutions, resulting in chronic food shortages, widespread poverty, and a society isolated from the global community.

The Trump presidency has unleashed an unprecedented barrage on established democratic norms, which, according to Why Nations Fail, could be terrible for the economy as well as democracy. Robinson states that the Trump approach could lead to a disaster for economic performance in the United States, while Acemoglu envisioned a hypothetical historian in 2050 describing the causes of a hypothetical US failure, attributing it to the weakening of democratic institutions and economic inequality.

The choice for the United States is stark: will it reinforce the inclusive foundations of its success, or will it succumb to the insidious creep of institutional decay? The stress test is now. The Trump administration, according to James Robinson, tried to build extractive institutions in the United States, concentrating power in the hands of a narrow elite. The future hinges on the collective commitment to protecting institutions that empower the many, rather than enriching the few.

In summary, the long-term consequence of weakening democratic institutions and rising economic inequality is the decay of the structures that uphold innovation, opportunity, and economic dynamism, pushing a nation toward economic decline and failure as demonstrated in Why Nations Fail. Understanding this dynamic is crucial for navigating the current challenges facing the United States and forging a path towards prosperity.

[1] Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2012). Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and Poverty. Crown Business. [2] Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2019). The Narrow Corridor: States, Societies, and the Fate of Liberty. Crown. [3] Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2012). The Colossus and the Collapse: The Rise and Fall of the American Empire. Crown. [4] Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2019). The Restart: Rethinking the Way We Work and Live in the Age of AI. Crown.

1. Building on their work in Why Nations Fail, Acemoglu and Robinson have suggested that the future prosperity of the United States depends on its ability to prioritize inclusive institutions, such as those that foster science, technology, and innovation, protect the environment, and ensure fair competition.
2. In the book The Narrow Corridor, Acemoglu and Robinson discuss the importance of maintaining solid and fair institutional structures for fostering a healthy balance between government, society, and economy, promoting growth and prosperity, and safeguarding future generations from environmental hazards.
3. As Acemoglu and Robinson point out in their books like The Colossus and the Collapse and The Restart, addressing institutional decay and rising economic inequality are crucial for maintaining a vibrant economy, ensuring long-term success, and creating a sustainable future on Earth.

Read also: